Image Source:Artificial Intelligence (illustration of a teacher at school)
Hi everyone, Shalom Aleichem!
Good evening GanSist everyone! 
Throughout the history of human civilization, various forms of punishment have been applied as a tool to punish criminals, maintain power, or provide a deterrent effect on society. Among the many execution methods that have been used, the crucifixion is often considered one of the most torturous forms of capital punishment. This punishment is not only aimed at taking a person’s life, but also humiliating, physically torturing, and causing extraordinary psychological suffering before death actually occurs.
The punishment of the cross was used by several ancient nations, including the Persians, Carthaginians, and was later perfected by the Roman Empire. The Romans made this punishment a symbol of state power. Usually, the punishment of the cross was imposed on slaves who rebelled, political rebels, robbers, or perpetrators of serious crimes. Roman citizens themselves were generally not subjected to this punishment, except in very serious cases of treason.
What made the punishment of the cross so terrible was not just the process of death, but the series of tortures that often preceded it. In many cases, the convict was first subjected to heavy whipping before being forced to carry a wooden beam to the execution site. After that, the victim was nailed or tied to a cross and left hanging for hours or even days until he died.
One of the most painful stages was whipping using a Roman whip (flagrum or flagellum). This whip is not an ordinary whip. At the ends of the rope were attached small metal balls and sharp pieces of bone. When hitting a victim’s body, the metal ball produces a violent impact that can cause deep bruising or hematoma, while bone fragments tear skin and soft tissue. The wounds caused are often so deep that the back muscles appear exposed.
Many historical and medical studies explain that whipping like this could cause blood loss of up to 1000 cc before the crucifixion process began. Apart from blood loss, victims also experience excruciating pain, fatigue due to continuous pain impulses, and a decrease in blood pressure. This condition made the body very weak even before being placed on the cross.
Apart from whipping, several historical narratives also describe the use of plaited prickly branches attached to the victim’s head. From an anatomical point of view, the scalp is a part of the body that is rich in blood vessels and filled with sensory nerve endings. Thorn pricks in the head do not cause fatal blood loss like large lacerations on the back caused by whipping, but they still produce very intense pain.
The pain not only comes from wounds on the scalp where hair grows, but also from injuries to the nerve branches around the forehead and face. Among these are branches of the trigeminal nerve, which is the main sensory nerve in the face. The trigeminal nerve is known to be very sensitive to painful stimuli. Activation of this nerve can cause pain that spreads to the roots of the teeth, eyeballs, cheeks and lips. In the world of modern medicine, disorders of the trigeminal nerve are even known as one of the causes of very severe facial pain.
It should be understood that persistent, severe pain in the face does not only cause psychological suffering. The body will release large amounts of stress hormones, heart rate increases, metabolism occurs excessively, and calories are depleted to maintain body functions. As a result, the victim becomes weaker and experiences severe physical fatigue just because they have to endure the pain in the face.
The next stage was nailing to the cross. In various historical studies, the nails were probably placed on the wrist or an area that was anatomically strong enough to support the body’s weight, not right in the palm of the hand as is often depicted in works of art. This section is passed by various important nerves, so that nail penetration causes excruciating pain in the metacarpal nerves. Likewise with the feet. One or more nails were used to hold the heels attached to the cross. The nail puncture wound that destroyed the heel bone caused bleeding, tissue damage, and pain that continued as long as the victim was alive.
What is often less understood is that the torture does not stop after the victim is nailed. In fact, the phase of hanging on the cross is one of the greatest causes of suffering. When a person hangs with his arms raised, the position of the chest cavity changes. The muscles that play a role in the breathing process have to work harder to expand the lungs. The victim can still breathe, but exhaling becomes increasingly difficult if the body is left hanging for a long time.
To be able to exhale more effectively, the victim usually had to push up with the two legs injured by the nails while pulling the body up using the two arms which were also badly injured by the whipping. Each movement causes the wound to rub against the wood, increases the pain of nail pricks in the hands and feet, and drains energy.
Over time, the victim becomes weaker due to blood loss, dehydration, intense pain and muscle fatigue. When energy runs out, the victim is no longer able to lift the body to breathe effectively. As a result, oxygen exchange becomes worse. This condition causes oxygen levels in the blood to decrease and carbon dioxide to increase. Ultimately, a combination of respiratory distress, intense pain, impaired circulation, and organ failure leads to death.
In some modern medical literature, the possibility is also discussed that the impact of the metal ball on a Roman whip could cause injury to internal organs if the impact was very strong. This kind of injury has the potential to cause bruising or hematoma in the visceral tissue. However, whether a hematoma actually reaches the lungs depends greatly on the location, force of the impact, and the condition of each person. Therefore, claims regarding pulmonary hematoma cannot be generalized to every victim of the cross, although severe chest trauma does allow injury to organs in the chest cavity.
In addition to physical suffering, the crucifixion was also designed as a form of public humiliation. Victims were usually executed in the open for the public to see. Wounded, exhausted, thirsty and unable to move bodies are a spectacle for many people. In the context of the Roman Empire, this goal was part of a political strategy to frighten society so that they would not revolt against the state.
The length of the death process varies greatly. There are victims who die within a few hours due to blood loss and severe trauma, but there are also those who survive for one to several days. Factors such as health conditions before execution, the severity of the whipping, weather, fluid intake, and the form of crucifixion also determine how long the victim can survive.
From the perspective of modern medicine, crucifixion is a combination of multiple injury mechanisms occurring simultaneously. The victim suffered serious injuries due to whipping, lack of blood, severe pain, dehydration, respiratory problems due to body position, extreme muscle fatigue, tissue perfusion problems, and ultimately organ failure due to severe hypovolemic shock. Not many ancient methods of punishment combined so many sources of suffering at once.
Although the crucifixion is often discussed in various religious and historical contexts, scientific research into its death mechanism remains important for understanding how the human body responds to severe trauma. Historians worked with forensic doctors, anatomists, and Roman history experts to reconstruct the process based on archaeological evidence, historical sources, and modern medical science.
Currently, the punishment of the cross has long been abandoned by most countries because it is contrary to human rights principles and the development of modern legal systems. The international community is increasingly emphasizing that punishment, whatever its form, must not involve torture or cruel and inhumane treatment.
By understanding the history of the cross through a scientific approach, we can see how the human civilization system has undergone major changes. What was once considered a means of maintaining power is now seen as an extreme example of the importance of respect for human dignity. This kind of history is not intended to romanticize violence, but rather serves as a reminder that the development of modern law was born from a long process of reducing practices that cause extraordinary suffering to fellow humans.
Quote:
